Columbia Business School Essay Topics & Insight, 2011–2012

This year, Columbia Business School (CBS) has posed three excellent essay questions to learn more about applicants. Please find the CBS Questions here, along with our analysis below.

Applying to CBS and other MBA programs this year? We encourage you to submit your essays, resume and/or letters of recommendation for our free  initial critique.

Cheers,

Ivy Eyes Editing

www.ivyeyesediting.com

***

1. Considering your post-MBA and long-term professional goals, why are you pursuing an MBA at this point in your career? Additionally, why is Columbia Business School a good fit for you? (Maximum of 750 words.)

We’ve written a variety of posts on MBA goals essays which we encourage you to read on our blog. With this question in particular, we like to provide our clients with a few important caveats:

-Why now? This is the MOST frequently overlooked dimension of this question. Whether you’re on a consulting or investment banking track—the key here is to show how an MBA program will elevate your career to the next level. You don’t need to be at a career impasse; you just need to demonstrate how an MBA will bolster your progress.

-Why Columbia? This is the second-most overlooked dimension of the prompt. It’s insufficient to write about the majestic rolling hills of CBS (there aren’t any), or even about a few professors’ work that inspires you. You must really drill down to the core of the program: what about the curriculum and career resources—how are they relevant to your needs? What about student organizations—how might you be poised to impact them? Remember that this is a great spot to not only say why CBS is your top choice, but also why you’re a great fit for CBS.

-Passion and Authenticity. As always, we push our clients to remember passion and authenticity in their MBA goals essays. While the prompt stipulates topics you must cover, be certain that your goals essay also has personal depth. What are goals without passionate, inspired vision?

2. Describe a life experience that has shaped you. The goal of this essay is to get a sense of who you are, rather than what you have achieved professionally. (Maximum of 500 words.)

For applicants that are uncomfortable with self-actualization, this question will be your nemesis. In the prompt, Columbia is asking for students to dig deep and think beyond their resume bullet points. If your goals essay came off detached, there’s absolutely no latitude for that here.

Creating a compelling narrative arc is critical for this essay (that’s right 8th grade English class: exposition, climax, denouement). Through your chosen life experience—which may be of the personal, professional, academic or extracurricular variety—you  must show self-reflection and growth. Do MBA admissions committees expect business leaders to possess values like integrity and authenticity? Absolutely! See our last post on the subject.

3. Essay three has three options (please choose one of the following):

Option A: The annual A. Lorne Weil Outrageous Business Plan Competition is a student initiative managed and run by the Columbia Entrepreneurs Organization (CEO). The competition encourages Columbia MBA students to explore creative entrepreneurial ideas that are sufficiently ambitious in scope and scale to be considered “outrageous.” Students explore these ideas while learning firsthand what goes into the development and presentation of a solid business proposal. Develop your own “outrageous” business idea. In essay form, compose your “elevator pitch.” (Maximum 250 words)

This isn’t a business plan competition; it is your ‘elevator pitch.’ That being said, the way you communicate your concept is ultimately more valuable than the concept itself.

So, think big–think “outrageous.” Of course, your concept must be viable on some level. Those that illustrate a clear lack of market forces or business acumen (“I’d like to bring back the VCR!”) will not be viewed favorably. The zaniest of ideas can be viable (a certain teleportation device case question comes to mind), but too zany will suggest you’re not taking the exercise seriously. Exercise good judgment.

Option B: Columbia deeply values its vibrant student community, the building of which begins at orientation when admitted students are assigned to clusters of 65 to 70 fellow students who take most of the first-year core classes together. During the first weeks of school, each cluster selects a Cluster Chair. Further strengthening the student community are the nearly 100 active student organizations at Columbia Business School, ranging from cultural to professional to community service-oriented. Leadership positions within the cluster and/or clubs offer hands-on management and networking opportunities for students as they interact with fellow students, administrators, faculty members, alumni, and practitioners. You are running for either Cluster Chair or a club leadership position of your choosing. Compose your campaign speech. (Maximum 250 words)

This is your opportunity to not again show that you are aware of the offerings at CBS, and the type of work CBS student organizations do. You must do your due diligence here. We recommend that clients compose this essay after a campus visit and speaking to students in the clubs that interest them. Use these initial conversations to harvest content and ideas for your essays! AdCom members know their student organizations well, and your investigative research will pay off.

Additionally, if you’ve ever delivered a campaign speech to your peers, you know what resonates the most. You can’t be too bold, too earnest, or too quirky—each approach bears a certain degree of risk and depends on the skill of the orator. In the essay context, we encourage applicants to experiment with a mix of these styles, resulting in essays that feel relatable, informed and also personality-charged.

Option C: Founded nearly three decades ago, the Executives in Residence Program at Columbia Business School integrates senior executives into the life of the School. Current executives in residence include more than a dozen experts in areas ranging from media and investment banking to private equity and management. A hallmark of the program is one-on-one counseling sessions in which executives advise students about their prospective career choices. Select one of the current executives in residence with whom you would like to meet during your time at Columbia. Explain your selection and tell us how you would best utilize your half hour one-on-one session. (Maximum 250 words)

Again, Columbia demonstrates the importance of knowing all there is to know about CBS before you apply.  They want students that are firmly committed to studying at CBS—people who will make the most of all opportunities there.

This essay should be a perfect complement to your goals essay. What are your professional objectives, and how might they align with or be informed by one of the executives in residence? 30 minutes is also not a long period of time; this essay therefore demands that you illustrate your ability to cooperate in a focused, pragmatic counseling session. Much like the ‘elevator pitch,’ you must think crisp like all seasoned business leaders….what questions are most important to your career, and what questions are best answered in an invaluable, one-on-one context?

An optional fourth essay will enable you to discuss any issues that do not fall within the purview of the required essays.

Use this space to address any questions surrounding your candidacy (such as your academic history, a low GMAT, professional gaps, etc.) or other salient personal or cultural elements that bear mention. If your essay might be inserted as an answer to another prompt, LEAVE IT BLANK. This is truly an ‘optional’ essay which should only be used when absolutely necessary to your candidacy.

Reapplicant Essay:

Submit one new essay: How have you enhanced your candidacy since your previous application? Please detail your progress since you last applied and reiterate your short-term and long-term goals. Explain how the tools of the Columbia MBA will help you to meet your goals and how you plan to participate in the Columbia community. (Maximum of 750 words.)

In this essay, growth and perspective are “clutch.” Chances are, your last application was lacking in some capacity—and newly clarified goals, professional and volunteer progress, and well-researched ‘fit’ with CBS can help you build a stronger case.

Picking the Right Medical School

Hi everyone,

This is a GREAT post from the AAMC’s Organization of Student Representatives (OSR) on picking the right medical school–a series of very thoughtful questions all medical school applicants should consider during their application research process.

Read below.

Cheers,
Ivy Eyes Editing
www.ivyeyesediting.com

***

Selecting a Medical School: Thirty-Five Questions I Wish I Had Asked

Medical schools, like individuals, are very different—in their philosophies, faculties, curricula, and the type of students they attract. As a result, selecting the “best” medical school for you can be challenging.

The following list of questions—compiled by medical students from across the country—is designed to help you evaluate the schools you will visit. This list is by no means complete; it was designed to serve as a base for your own questions. Make sure to research each institution before the interview so you can ask informed questions.

The interview represents a valuable learning opportunity for you, so don’t be shy about asking anyone your questions. Congratulations on your career choice and good luck with your interviews!

Curriculum

1. Are there any special programs for which this medical school is noted?
2. Please tell me more about the integrated curriculum.
3. What modalities are used for student lectures?
4. What are the opportunities for research? What are the policies for taking time off for research opportunities?
5. How do students get assistance if an academic need arises?
6. Is there flexibility in the coursework (the number of electives) and the timing of the courses (accelerating, decelerating, and time off) during the pre-clinical and clinical years?
7. Are standardized tests used such as the NBME shelf exams?
8. Has this medical school, or any of its clinical departments, been on probation or had its accreditation revoked?
9. How do students from this medical school perform on the National Board Examinations? How does the school assist students who do not pass?

Evaluations

10. How are students evaluated academically? How are clinical evaluations performed?
11. Is there a formal mechanism in place for students to evaluate their professors and attending physicians? What changes have been made recently as a result of this feedback?

Counseling/Student Support

12. What kind of academic, personal, financial, and career counseling is available to students? Are these services also offered to their spouses and dependents/children?
13. Is there a mentor/advisor system? Who are the advisors—faculty members, other students, or both?
14. How diverse is the student body? Are there support services or organizations for ethnic/cultural minorities, LGBT students, and women?

Facilities

15. Tell me about the library and extracurricular facilities (i.e., housing and athletic/recreational facilities). Is designated study space available?
16. Are students required to have a laptop?
17. What type of clinical sites—ambulatory, private preceptors, private hospitals, rural settings, international—are available or required for clerkships? Does this school allow for students to do rotations at other institutions or internationally?
18. Is a car necessary for clinical rotations? Is parking a problem?

Financial Aid

19. What is the current tuition and fees? Is this expected to increase yearly? If so, at what rate?
20. Are there stable levels of federal financial aid and substantial amounts of university/medical school endowment aid available to students?
21. Are there students who have an “unmet need” factor in their budget? If so, how do these students come up with the extra funds?
22. Are spouses and dependents/children covered in a student’s budget?
23. Are there services/staff available to assist students with budgeting and financial planning?
24. Does this school provide guidance to its students and to its graduates/alumni, on debt management?

Student Involvement

25. What medical school committees (e.g., curriculum committee) have student representation?
26. Are students involved in (required or voluntary) community service?
27. How active is the student council/government? Are there other active student organizations?

Policies

28. What is the student medical insurance coverage and what is the cost to students?
29. Is there an established protocol for dealing with student exposure to infectious diseases?
30. Does this school provide, or does the student pay for, vaccinations against Hepatitis B or prophylactic AZT treatment in case of a needle-stick or accident?
31. Is disability insurance provided to cover exposure?
32. Is there a school honor code? Is there a grievance process/procedure? Are the students involved?

Residency

33. May I see a list of residency programs to which this school’s recent graduates were accepted?

Questions to Ask Yourself

34. Does this school have strengths in the type of medicine (primary versus specialized care, urban versus rural practice environment, academic medicine versus private practice) that I will want to practice?
35. Would I be happy at this school for at least the next four years?

Ivy Eyes Editing: Our Approach To the Editing Process

The admissions process is growing more and more competitive. This is not news to anyone. Most college, MBA, medical school, law school and other graduate program application numbers are all on the rise.

With this exponential increase, the admissions consultation industry continues to expand and evolve. Applicants are inundated with advisors, independent consultants, and all types of mentors to steer and optimize their application process. “We’ll help you improve your test scores so that you are competitive. We’ll edit your essays to convey more polish and sophistication. We’ll guide you through the admissions process and strengthen your personal brand.” There is a broad spectrum of ethical standards when it comes to this ever-growing market, and we would like to share more about ours.

Ivy Eyes Editing was founded in 2005 by Yale graduates to tackle this market in a different way. We work with all types of applicants to push their thinking, develop authentic content through intellectual partnership, and build writing skills for the future. As editors, this process is more fulfilling for our team, and as former students, this ethical standard is paramount.

Consider the following excerpt from a recent admissions essay:

“1. What are you most passionate about? Why? (250 word maximum)

I am most passionate about corporate responsibility and social justice, and exploring how businesses can profitably advance human rights. My father fled Cambodia in 1976, leaving dozens of family members behind. As an undergraduate at the University of Texas, I learned about the brutal 1994 genocide in Rwanda and was shocked that despite the historical lessons we have learned as a society, another genocide had occurred in my lifetime. Shortly thereafter, I joined a group of students working to raise awareness about the ongoing conflict in Iraq.”

With this opening paragraph to a short essay, we suggested that the applicant truly target the prompt. The prompt says it all here, and we encourage all applicants to convey passion from the onset of the essay. We might ask: what are the real details of your family history? How can the transition from a family history linked to Rwanda to Iraq be strengthened and substantiated? How can you show that a personal history cemented values which translated into action?

These questions drive clients to share more color on their experience and literally present a more complete picture of themselves. From our point of view, the best writing does not possess the most sophisticated, refined prose; the best writing is able to ask the toughest questions. After the initial critique, candidates email us back with answers to our targeted questions.

An interesting theme has emerged through this process: the content that is needed to fill gaps in these essays is almost always explicitly present in clients’ answers. In fact, in most cases there is little content tweaking involved; we simply integrate clients’ answers directly into the essay, and help with stylistic polish. What does this say about our process?

As with any other consultation businesses, the key is not in taking ownership of clients’ work, but in driving clients to achieve their goals within their own brand. In other words, Ivy Eyes Editing is not seeking to transform a quotidian, poorly constructed, underdeveloped essay into a PhD-level masterpiece. Instead, we work as consultants and thought partners with clients, helping them to write at their fullest potential and develop effective ways to distill their unique stories, cultivate their narrative voices and market their successes.

As writers, what we impose is an emphasis on story-building. Even for the most sterile and empirical prompts, we encourage constructing narrative arcs (exposition, climax, denouement) and building depth through the use of multiple layers and threads.

In the admissions space, this approach is crucial. While some services produce essays that sound compelling, in many cases, applicants cannot speak to the content that is in front of them. How does this translate into the interview setting? How does this help candidates in both the short-term and the long-term? Ultimately, helping candidates craft stories that truly reflect their experience and purpose will be most valuable.

We hope this gives more general insight into our process. Email us today for a free assessment to see how we work, and how we can help you make your writing the most positive, compelling and accurate reflection of you.

Best of luck!

Ivy Eyes Editing
www.ivyeyesediting.com

Medical Admissions Writing Tip Series: Explaining Low Grades

Hello everyone,

If you’re human, chances are your undergraduate grades are not absolutely perfect. We confront this issue with our clients (applying to medical programs or elsewhere) on a regular basis. What are some key tactics to keep in mind when explaining low grades in admissions writing?

-Keep your justification focused. It’s important that you don’t try to boil the ocean here, even if you truly grappled with the death of a family member, an ADHD diagnosis, a broken foot and mild depression. Applicants that cite too many reasons for poor academic performance will sound like they’re just making excuses (a weakness in itself), rather than voicing a legitimate circumstance.

-Circumstantial conditions work; abstract emotional conditions do not. Your freshman year may have been an intense period of self-exploration. You have confronted new insecurities, or lost focus due to adapting to a radically different environment. Welcome to freshman year. In the application context, a concrete justification is more likely to hold water.

-Couch weakness in a strength. What’s most important is how you responded to your lapse in academic performance, not the low grades themselves. How much did your grades improve after you regained your footing? What other activities did you take on or reprioritize? What did you learn?

-Explain low grades only if you MUST. Remember that nearly every applicant has some kind of blemish on their academic record. In many cases, a dip in academic performance does not even require contextualization (such as that B+ in Orgo). So, think carefully about whether and how you discuss your academic misstep.

-Strategically position the weakness paragraph. You don’t want your closing paragraph to resonate on your academic foibles–you want to save that space for new analysis and marketing your greatest strengths.

Best of luck, and as always, feel free to email us for a free critique of your admissions materials–including personal statements, experience descriptions, CV’s, recommendation letters and more!!!

Cheers,

Ivy Eyes Editing

www.ivyeyesediting.com

Medical Admissions Writing Tip Series: How to Write a Great Intro

Hi everyone,

In this post, we’re going to reveal the formula for how to write a captivating introductory paragraph for your AMCAS, TMDSAS, AADSAS or ERAS personal statement. The magic recipe is as follows:

There is no recipe–and that’s the problem.

With the majority of personal statements that we read, it’s apparent that applicants are getting more admissions-savvy. At least they think they are. However, with this evolution in admissions writing comes a great number of narrative trends, which at some point, become cliches. For example, the introductory paragraphs that we read typically fall into the following categories:

-The allegory or outside-the-box event. Rife with evocative description and figurative language. Typically starts with a high stakes condition–such as the tension-filled finish of a track race–and then returns in the conclusion with a substance-less axiom like ‘life’s a race.’

-The shock-and-awe medical experience. A volunteering post in Sudan wherein multiple human atrocities were witnessed, or a shadowing experience at a pediatric hospital. This approach hinges on the deceptively winnable challenge of surprising a reader who has already seen or heard it all.

-The personal health issue. One person’s bout with ulcerative colitis or diabetes, and the resultant window into a medical career. This paragraph makes the claim that a personal health condition has provided the catalyst for a career in medicine (which is most frequently problematic and should be avoided).

Of course, none of these approaches are completely off-limits if handled with appropriate finesse. However, we push our clients to simply think BEYOND them, and to not be constrained by the other introductory paragraphs they’re reading. There is more to your story. Moreover, once your statement progresses, if you don’t sustain the impact of your introduction, your essay will fall flat. And once your reader’s attention is lost, there’s little chance of regaining it!

While writing your introduction, keep in mind that it is not your golden ticket; the rest of your personal statement requires equally sophisticated storytelling. Also remember that if your introductory paragraph is not in one of the three categories mentioned above, that is perfectly ok. Ultimately, there’s no template for a phenomenal personal statement, other than writing with an authentic, bold style that is uniquely your own.

Cheers,

Ivy Eyes Editing

www.ivyeyesediting.com

 

Hyphens and Dashes Are Not Interchangeable

Stop! Go back and re-read the title above—at least 2–3 times—then let it sink in before continuing.

The sentence above illustrates the proper use of the hyphen and the two main types of dashes. They are not the same, and must not be confused with each other. In some fancy fonts the difference is more than just the width—hyphens have a distinct serif. If you don’t know the rules already, let’s review:

An “em” is a unit of measurement defined as the point size of the font—12 point type uses a 12 point “em.” An “en” is one-half of an “em.”

Though some of the finer points in the rules are complex, their basic applications are clear-cut and their misuse easily identifiable. First, neither an em dash nor an en dash should be confused with the hyphen (-), which is used to join compound words together.

The correct use of em and en

The em dash (—) is used to indicate a sudden break in thought (“I was thinking about writing a—what time did you say the movie started?”), a parenthetical statement that deserves more attention than parentheses indicate, or instead of a colon or semicolon to link clauses. It is also used to indicate an open range, such as from a given date with no end yet (as in “Peter Sheerin [1969—] authored this document.”), or vague dates (as a stand-in for the last two digits of a four-digit year).

Two adjacent em dashes (a 2-em dash) are used to indicate missing letters in a word (“I just don’t f——ing care about 3.0 browsers”).

Three adjacent em dashes (a 3-em dash) are used to substitute for the author’s name when a repeated series of works are presented in a bibliography, as well as to indicate an entire missing word in the text.

The en dash (–) is used to indicate a range of just about anything with numbers, including dates, numbers, game scores, and pages in any sort of document.

It is also used instead of the word “to” or a hyphen to indicate a connection between things, including geographic references (like the Mason–Dixon Line) and routes (such as the New York–Boston commuter train).

It is used to hyphenate compounds of compounds, where at least one pair is already hyphenated (as in “Netscape 6.1 is an Open-Source–based browser.”). The Chicago Manual of style also states that it should be used “Where one of the components of a compound adjective contains more than one word,” instead of a hyphen (as in “Netscape 6.1 is an Open Source–based browser”). Both of these rules are for clarity in indicating exactly what is being modified by the compound.

Other sources also specify the use of an en dash when referring to joint authors, as in the “Bose–Einstein” paper. Some also prefer it to a hyphen when text is set in all capital letters.

Some typographers prefer to use an en dash surrounded by full spaces instead of an em dash. Others prefer to insert hair spaces on either side of the em dash, but this is problematic with some web browsers (see the section on spaces for more detail).
Hyphenate This

That hyphen you can insert with the key next to the zero on your keyboard is an ambiguous character suffering from an identity crisis. It can’t decide if it’s a hyphen, a minus, or an en dash—in fact, the Unicode specification describes it as “hyphen-minus” and defines very specific replacements for each of its personalities.

Use it if you need to insert a hyphen, but never for a minus (−) or a dash, since it does not have the correct width for either, or the vertical position for the latter (compare “1+4-2=3” to “1+4−2=3”).

The soft hyphen (­ a.k.a. “discretionary hyphen” and “optional hyphen”) is to be used for one purpose only—to indicate where a word may be broken at the end of a line. Otherwise, it is to remain invisible and not affect the appearance of the word.

As you are working on your medical personal statements, MBA application or CommonApp essays, please keep these distinctions in mind.

Happy hyphenating!

Ivy Eyes Editing
www.ivyeyesediting.com

*Working on your AMCAS, TMDSAS, AADSAS or ERAS personal statement? Email us for a free critique!’

Medical Admissions Writing Series: I Always Knew I Wanted to be a Doctor…

Hi everyone,

If you’re writing your AMCAS or TMDSAS personal statement, or getting a head start on secondary essays, you’ve likely taken multiple stabs at your introductory paragraph.

Somewhere, in one of your drafts, you’ve also probably attempted to pinpoint the precise moment when your passion for medicine was born. The majority of applicants will fall prey to the chronic default (“I always knew I wanted to be a doctor…”) at some point or another. Some will cite a prodigious talent for the board game Operation as an early indicator for a career in cardiology; others opt to refer to a singular incident with a homeless person as the catalyst behind the desire to ‘serve the underserved.’ Our vehement advice: fight the impulse!

Instead, let your interest evolve naturally; don’t force it. Your passion for medicine should be evidenced by your background, your research, your clinical experience, your activities, and your current reflections. Childhood ambitions change, and with good reason! If they hadn’t, I would be a priest right now :) Additionally, there’s something highly problematic about suggesting your childhood empathy is a uniquely intrinsic trait. Let’s face it: aren’t most kids fundamentally empathetic? I know, I know–but you were the ultimate empath! :)

So remember, when crafting your medical personal statement, avoid claiming a “prezygotic” interest in medicine–your essay will be infinitely more sophisticated, organic and persuasive because of it.

Cheers,

Janson
Ivy Eyes Editing
www.ivyeyesediting.com

Medical Admissions Writing Tip Series: Utilizing the AMCAS Activities/Experience Descriptions Section

As most of you know, this year, the AMCAS application rules have changed slightly. One of these changes has impacted the experience descriptions. Instead of 15 opportunities (1325 characters) to write about experiences, answers are now limited to 700 characters. Furthermore, of these 15 experiences, AMCAS applicants have been tasked with describing up to 3 experiences which they consider most meaningful. These answers are limited to 1325 characters each (beyond the original 700 character allotment).

What does this mean for the applicant? We believe this update puts a higher premium on both brevity and truly getting to know the applicant. Here are some helpful hints to consider in polishing your 700 character, general descriptions:

  • First, start with a broad list of all your activities; then, think critically about which are important and meaningful to you. Citing 15, 700-characters-on-the-dot experiences doesn’t guarantee an A+ (your lack of enthusiasm for your 3-week stint in genetics research will be readily apparent to your reader.) Also, any experience may be medical school interview fodder—so you don’t want to be caught offguard. All 15 experiences should be ‘meaningful’ on some level!
  • Find creative ways to conserve space: don’t repeat doctors’ names, lengthy titles, department names, etc. DO show unique, valuable and transferable clinical skills; DON’T repeat basic skills across experiences just to fill the space.
  • Omit high school activities unless they represent substantive, increased levels of participation, leadership or responsibility in your undergraduate career. That includes piano lessons, though we know you dedicated 14,031 hours to tickling those ivories.
  • Don’t include trivial hobbies (and let’s be honest–who doesn’t enjoy the occasional Poker or Flip Cup game).
  • If the organization in which you participated is not nationally recognized, provide a brief description followed by the role you played there. Also, don’t use obsolete acronyms–spell out all organization names for your reader’s sake.
  • If you earned a spot on the Dean’s list for more than one semester, use the description area to list the other semesters. If you received a scholarship, fellowship or other honor that is not nationally recognizable, concisely explain it.
  • When listing a publication, ensure that it is properly cited. If the paper is being “prepared for submission” or “submitted,” include this fact as part of the research description in the part where you listed the research activity.

For the 1325 character ‘meaningful descriptions,’ think about the following:

  • Though some experiences may be meaningful for similar reasons, each answer is an opportunity to showcase your personal values. So, stretch yourself and show variety in your answers. Why did your NASA research matter to you, and what does this say about you? How did this differ from the gratification you felt from your Alzheimer’s research?
  • Use stories and specific anecdotes to color each answer. In recounting stories, you may unearth motivations that you had not previously considered.
  • DON’T repeat skills and responsibilities in these long answers—1325 characters is still 1-2 paragraphs at most. Utilize this space to show how you think, and what matters to you.
  • Your language should be mechanically sound—but we recommend that our clients keep the tone as conversational as possible. It’s difficult to relate what makes an experience meaningful, so why cripple that response with pedantic, stilted language?

In general, remember to keep your activities section crisp and focused. Take time fleshing out the most valuable dimensions of each experience. If written well, these activities can effectively complement your personal statement and elevate your AMCAS application.

As always, feel free to reach out to Ivy Eyes for a free critique of your activities descriptions (in addition to personal statements, resumes and recommendations).

Best of luck!!!

Cheers,

Ivy Eyes Editing

www.ivyeyesediting.com

Medical Admissions Writing Tip Series: Emotional Manipulation vs Authenticity

Living in Los Angeles means living at the epicenter of film fanaticism. Here, a film is sacrosanct–viewed as a transportive looking glass and siphon for human truth. Lars von Trier is frequently lambasted for what is seen as the cardinal sin of the directing world: work that is devoid of emotional authenticity and integrity. But why are integrity and authenticity so important to consider in films? Because they are a reflection of the auteur and the intention behind the work, both of which bind us to fictitious characters and stories capable of permeating our realities.

In Midnight in Paris, Woody Allen’s parody of Ernest Hemingway says flatly, “No subject is terrible if the story is true and if the prose is clean and honest.” Gertrude Stein, analyzing one of Picasso’s latest paintings, says, “Sure there’s universality, but there’s no objectivity.” Again, we see the premium placed on authentic, balanced and self-aware artistic output.

But why is all this so important?

In a recent interaction with a prospective client, and after re-reading his AMCAS personal statement several times, I realized what I felt: subtly emotionally manipulated. “In the doleful eyes of Joshua, a 9-year-old who would hopefully benefit from our research, I saw his future and his hope. He hugged me tenderly, and in that moment, I knew medicine was the path for me.” Cue violins! He had also painted stark, vivid portraits of the realities he had seen as a volunteer medical assistant in Sudan; however, at a certain point, his prodigious, solution-oriented leadership gave way to the harrowing details of his environment. In admissions writing, it’s important to stay authentic, but also stay focused on the primary goal: conveying your readiness to enter medical school and become a physician.

This prospective client also had an enviable list of international volunteering experiences. And while they were all artfully integrated into the personal statement, the writing still lacked the resonance necessary to compel an admissions committee. It felt like an over-developed resume. The purpose of the personal statement, of course, should be to humanize your resume and fill in the interstitial spaces. Over the course of telling great stories, consider: have I still shown that I have something left to learn, or do I sound too seasoned? Have I marketed my existing skills? Have I voiced uncertainty? What’s the real reason behind sharing a specific anecdote or experience?

Aldous Huxley said of Hemingway’s style, “He writes in the white spaces between the lines.” Does your writing resonate like this, or does it overwhelm and saturate the page? At Ivy Eyes Editing, we believe that there’s no one-size-fits-all roadmap for authentic writing: your voice is a sum of your experiences and your ability to reflect on them. However, it’s in this reflection process where we come in, and help our clients to find the balance required for true authenticity.

Cheers,

Janson

www.ivyeyesediting.com

Medical School Admissions: Stats from US News

Hi everyone,

US News recently released data on the 10 Most Popular Medical Schools–please read some key excerpts and stats below. As you begin your medical school application process, these numbers may be helpful to you in determining where to apply (and where you’ll be facing steep competition).

Cheers,

Ivy Eyes Editing

www.ivyeyesediting.com

***

10 Most Popular Medical Schools

The University of Kansas Medical Center is the nation’s most popular medical school, according to an analysis of yield data by U.S. News.

A school’s yield is the percentage of admitted students who opt to enroll in the program. At Kansas, 176—or 82.2 percent—of the 214 accepted students chose to attend the school in the academic year beginning in 2010, narrowly edging out the University of Nevada—Reno School of Medicine, where 62 students, or 81.6 percent of the 76 accepted, enrolled last year.

Of the top 10 most popular medical schools, only one—the University of Washington School of Medicine—placed in the top 10 of U.S. News‘s rankings of medical school research programs. Only two—Washington and the University of North Carolina—Chapel Hill School of Medicine—of the most popular schools cracked the top 50 of that ranking.

However, five of the most popular medical schools were ranked among the top 50 primary care programs, including 14th-ranked Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine and the 41st-ranked University of Kansas Medical Center.

Each school on the list of most popular medical schools is a state institution, which likely contributes to the popularity of each, since tuition for in-state students at public medical schools is significantly lower than tuition for out-of-state students or at private schools. At the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, for instance, in-state tuition is $16,170 compared to $46,347 out of state.

Of the 10 most popular medical schools, all have yield percentages of more than 70 percent, while the national average among the 121 schools that provided yield data to U.S. News is 50.2 percent. Below is a list of the 10 most popular medical schools, sorted by percentage yield among new students in 2010:

School Name Students Accepted Students Enrolled Yield Percentage U.S. News Research Rank U.S. News Primary Care Rank
University of Kansas Medical Center 214 176 82.2% 71 41
University of Nevada–Reno School of Medicine 76 62 81.6% Rank Not Published* 92
University of New Mexico School of Medicine 117 94 80.3% 87 28
University of Washington School of Medicine 272 216 79.4% 9 1
University of North Dakota School of Medicine & Health Sciences 79 62 78.5% RNP 66
University of Oklahoma College of Medicine 213 165 77.5% 84 92
University of South Dakota Sanford School of Medicine 71 54 76.1% RNP 58
University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill School of Medicine 215 160 74.4% 20 2
Medical University of South Carolina College of Medicine 211 156 73.9% 60 58
Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine 435 318 73.1% RNP 14

RNP denotes an institution that is ranked in the bottom one fourth of all medical and osteopathic schools. U.S. News calculates a rank for the school but has decided not to publish it.